Log in

No account? Create an account

McKinley's Disputed Quote: "uplift and civilize and Christianize them" - Myths_Americana

About McKinley's Disputed Quote: "uplift and civilize and Christianize them"

Previous Entry McKinley's Disputed Quote: "uplift and civilize and Christianize them" Mar. 9th, 2007 @ 03:27 pm
In our most recent posting on "Pretexts for War," we used a widely cited quotation from President William McKinley. George Mason University has posted it with this framing note, followed by its canonical source citation. "In an interview with a visiting church delegation published in 1903, President William McKinley defends his decision to support the annexation of the Philippines in the wake of the U.S. war in that country.

When I next realized that the Philippines had dropped into our laps I confess I did not know what to do with them. . . And one night late it came to me this way. . .1) That we could not give them back to Spain- that would be cowardly and dishonorable; 2) that we could not turn them over to France and Germany-our commercial rivals in the Orient-that would be bad business and discreditable; 3) that we not leave them to themselves-they are unfit for self-government-and they would soon have anarchy and misrule over there worse than Spain's wars; and 4) that there was nothing left for us to do but to take them all, and to educate the Filipinos, and uplift and civilize and Christianize them, and by God's grace do the very best we could by them, as our fellow-men for whom Christ also died.
Source: General James Rusling, “Interview with President William McKinley,” The Christian Advocate 22 January 1903. The meeting had occurred on November 21, 1899.

A passerby to Myths_Americana observed that Lewis Gould's The Presidency of William McKinley (Lawrence: The Regents Press of Kansas, 1980) disputes the accuracy of the religious portion of this quotation (p. 141), expressing suspicion toward James F. Rusling. Wikipedia has popularized this doubt with a section labeled Disputed Quotation. Its authenticity is important to history writing, because it has been cited in this form so often on nothing more than Rusling's authority. While I can't really prove that McKinley said it, I believe that there are persuasive circumstances surrounding it and an independent confirmation that Gould ignored. I divide the issue into (a) the contestability of the "president on his knees" report, and (b) the evidence regarding the the quote's language.

Two Presidents on their Knees in Prayer?. Gould is rightly suspicious that Rusling would print stories of two different presidents--Lincoln and McKinley--praying for divine guidance about their wars and then reporting it to Rusling. Rusling, who had risen to Brigadier General during the Civil War before he became a historian, wrote about Lincoln in the first chapter of his Men and Things I Saw in Civil War Days (1899). This book is now, but Google's project has rescued Men and Things, so that we can study what Gould found to be the source of suspicious parallels. Rusling does not in fact assert that Lincoln made the disclosure to him alone, but to General Dan Sickles, whose leg was shatered by a cannon ball at the Battle of Gettsyburg. It was Sickles himself, recovering from his amputation, who posed a question to Lincoln about his thought process during the Gettysburg ordeal. Rusling happened to be present. Since Sickles was a famous/notorious person, the story likely circulated often after the 1863 hospital encounter. Sickles later became a member of the U.S. House of Representatives, living until 1914. As regards the authenticity of the account, Rusling's Men and Things includes an Appendix relating to , and it includes correspondence with Sickles himself, who cannot confirm that Rusling had the exact words right. Sickles after all, was still suffering from the recent amputation of his leg in 1863, and Rusling's initial published account in 1892 came 25 years after the event. (See pages 355ff for the various confirmations that Rusling offers as well as the earlier published version.) In an important qualificaton to his skepticism, Gould notices that McKinley himself had used the Lincoln-on-his-knees-in-prayer story in a speech he gave in 1892 (note 36, p. 266). Could it be that McKinley had received his version from Rusling, enjoyed it, liked its effect on his audience--and then used the heart of the story later to give a religious stamp to to his account of meditation on the Philippines. In seeing the matter that way, McKinley leans on Rusling, rather than Rusling leaning on his earlier story to recast McKinley.

The Religious Context. Gould's book is not attentive to religion or to the significant role of the Methodist Church in McKinley's life. In this regard, Gary Scott Smith's essay "William McKinley: America as God's Instrument" is far more instructive because he pays attention to McKinley's life a man solidly grounded in the Methodist Episcopal Church. Beyond quoting Rusling's Christian Advocate article to call it into question, Gould did not include the Methodists' own history of their relationships with McKinley as president. J. Tremayne Copplestone's History of Methodist Missions, Vol. IV: Twentieth Century Perspectives (The Methodist Episcopal Church, 1896-1986 (New York: The Board of Global Ministries/The United Methodist Church, 1973) tells a decisive story here. The Methodists, like other groups in American society, experienced the expansionist/imperial fever. Matthew T. Herbst has described how one Annual Conference acted in the heat of the imperial moment in his well documented essay "Michigan Methodism and Aggressive Christianity." Once the war with Spain was underway, Methodist foreign mission advocates saw the Philippines as both fertile target and a kind of beachhead that could be used for more effective launches of evangelism into Asia. The Methodists began to lobby McKinley early and often for the right to missionize the Philippines, which was dominated by the Catholics prior to its annexation by the United States. As the Methodists put it, they wanted "complete religious toleration" (Copplestone, 174, citing a Sept. 6, 1898 letter from the Missionary Society of the Methodist Church ) and the freedom for competition with the Catholics, who were linked in their minds with heathen superstition, idolatry, and political tyranny. As relates to the authenticity of the quotation, Bishop James M. Thoburn, prior to the famous August 21, 1899 meeting of the Missionary Comittee with McKinley, had a private audience with the president to plead the Methodist case for permission to evangelize. and this session supplemented a White House reception for the Committee in the Blue Room with Admirals Dewey and Schley. (Copplestone, p. 187) Three days later the delegation from the Missionary Committee, which included Rusling, came to the White House to thank the president for the encouragement given to Bishop Thoburn for their ventures. In that session the Committee members read to McKinley a statement saying: "The Methodist Episcopal Church believes in the dignity, the dignity and the destiny of this Great Republic as a Providential institution among men--to uplift, and civilize, and christianize our fellow men." (Copplestone, p. 188) This written statement and details surrounding the meeting appeared in the "Minutes, General Missionary Committee" for November 9, 10, 15, 18, 21--the last being the exact date of the meeting with McKinley. (Copplestone's source notes, p. 1217) It has often been observed that no member of the committee ever contradicted Rusling's account. Why would they, since McKinley was simply repeating the language read to him? They were all Methodists with a shared missionary purpose and spoke the same language to one another. It's true that McKinley in his public rhetoric spoke more vaguely about "the duties of civilization" and that is doubtless why Gould could not believe that McKinley would have spoken so fervently about a world religious mission for America. McKinley was sensitive about his public audiences and could politically tune the level of secularity/religiosity in his rhetoric. In this case of the disputed quote, with documentary evidence that he was merely repeating the language brought to his private chamber by his religious peers, there seems little reason to question it.

In my opinion, it is not the quotation that should now be disputed, but the doubt about its authenticity. One could go to those same archives that Copplestone drew upon as he wrote the history for the Methodist Church. It is always possible to learn something new from a second look.

John Shelton Lawrence March 8, 2007
Leave a comment
Date:November 29th, 2007 09:27 pm (UTC)

Forgive that beside You was little ed!

Excellent forum with fantastic references and reading.... well done indeed...
All the best!
Date:February 3rd, 2008 07:46 am (UTC)

Проститутки Днепропетровска досуг dosug sex Девушки

Проститутки Днепропетровска интим dosug sex Девушки
наш сайт http://kurtizanka.com.ua
Date:April 5th, 2008 08:15 pm (UTC)

What i can find on this forum ? I new here

Date:April 8th, 2008 10:18 am (UTC)

What i can find on this forum ? I new here

Hey people. Best canadina pharmacy here:
Date:April 10th, 2008 02:49 pm (UTC)

What i can find on this forum ? I new here

Hey people. Best canadina pharmacy here:
Date:May 2nd, 2009 09:38 am (UTC)

Ugrently need your help!

Hi, my friends... I want to get program XRUMER 5.07 Palladium for FREE. Have you any download link???
I'm so need this magic program! It's can break captchas automatically! Activate accounts via email automatically too! Absolutely great software! Help me!
And did you hear news - price for XRumer 5.0 Palladium will grow up to $540 after 15 may 2009... And XRumer 2.9 and 3.0 - too old versions, it's cant break modern catpchas and cant break modern anti-bot protections. But XRumer 5.0 Palladium CAN!!!!
So help me for download this great soft for free! Thanks!
Date:January 9th, 2011 12:44 pm (UTC)

thibqrph ietj

ggxaawl wdi talcl hardcore whores (http://www.hardcoreporn234.com/hardcore whores.html)


ujity vhvtto yai black sluts (http://www.ebonyporn234.com/black sluts.html)
Date:January 11th, 2011 04:50 pm (UTC)

Put the screws on Climbing Wall Rentals Los Angeles?

Residing in the Town has it's recompense however similar with all stuff, there appears to be certainly a draw back too! Living in the core of the act is critical, as you ought to be in the circle. My boss, Armando, always talks about these things. In reality, he spends the better part of the daylight hours to reason just about things similar to these things. Nevertheless, for my friends Israel, Darlene and Leonardo, our Town is the single space to exist. For my person this urban being is cool! I don't go to see the clubs. I rather choose a pleasant Storage place Party and including the assistance of [url=http://boomerevents.com/index.php]Climbing Wall Rentals Los Angeles[/url] it certainly is permanently a irreplaceable happening!
Life needs us all moreover us all want occasionally more or less serious regeneration, to find a way to sustain with this day by day stress!!
I'm Lindsay Nicholson and I trust your next birthday party will be a blow!
Date:January 16th, 2011 07:11 pm (UTC)

Кузовной сервис, покраска авто в Питере, Купчино, скидк

Господа, здравствуйте! Предлагаю посетить мой! Вот небольшое описание:

Санкт - Петербрг, Купчино. Предлагаем свои услуги по кузовному ремонту Вашего автомобиля!
Исправление после ДТП с исправлением геометрии кузова, покраска авто в камере - локальная, преходом и полная, замена несущих элементов конструкции, стапель, сварка, рихтовка, вклейка стекол, выставление зазоров элементов, и т.д.
Цены на ремонт низкие - смотрите на нашем сайте! Оценка повреждений по фото, выезд мастера для осмотра авто бесплатный.
Предлагаем любые кузовные запчасти, оптику, стекла для иномарки со склада и на заказ (срок поставки от 2-х дней) по самым низким ценам, оригинал и неоригинал.
Гарантия на все работы.
8 931 227 20 47
Если запостил ошибочно - извините!
Date:January 17th, 2011 07:23 am (UTC)

painter 11

Well … all I can say is, wow. This is an impressive collection of resources, thank you for taking the time to put everything together.
Date:February 4th, 2011 04:54 am (UTC)

gapqohwa rgwz

kjef skstu xxx (http://www.porntubehunter.com) gbduxu o yz w bdc
Date:February 12th, 2011 08:56 am (UTC)

vuitton bags

Completely I share your opinion. It is excellent idea. It is ready to support you.
Date:April 13th, 2011 01:16 am (UTC)

Can't wait to have my say

Hey - I am really happy to find this. Good job!
(Leave a comment)
Top of Page Powered by LiveJournal.com